I think Holden Caulfield is/was being treated for tuberculous meningitis

 When Holden is addressing us in the “present tense” context of The Catcher in the Rye, it’s clear to the readers that his current environment is purposefully vague. However, the brief amount of description of his surroundings suggests to a fairly likely theory that he is being held in some sort of mental health facility. At the beginning of the book, Holden says that he’s going to “just tell you about this madman stuff… just before I got pretty run-down and had to come out here and take it easy” (3).  It’s very clear to us by the end of the book that Holden is not only having a mental health crisis, but also a physical one. This would align well with the fact that the time period of The Catcher likely doesn’t have very good resources for mental health conditions, and provide a societal motivation for why the people around him would choose to have him go to some sort of psychiatric ward— if not for his rampant depression, than for the potential tuberculosis he might have caught. 

My diagnosis of tuberculosis is mainly supported by Holden’s statement of page 8, where he was describing his general physical condition: “I have no wind, if you want to know the truth. I’m quite a heavy smoker… I used to be. They made me cut it out… I practically got t.b. And came out here for all these goddam checkups and stuff.” Difficulty with breathing is a well known symptom of tuberculosis, and Holden’s self-described past habit of smoking definitely did not help with that, and likely lowered his immune response. Additionally, his statement that a mysterious “they” forced him to stop his perpetual habit of smoking— likely to improve his health, mentally or physically, further supports his institutionalization. 

At the end of the book, Holden admits himself that he had physically gotten sick, if it hadn’t been clear enough when he gradually described his symptoms through the book’s events. In the last chapter, chapter 26, he says “I could probably tell you… how I got sick.” That’s okay, Holden, in the previous chapter alone, you describe about 10 different symptoms all implicating some underlying infection being brought to the surface: intense headache, a cold sore or something like that, lack of appetite, paranoia, auditory hallucinations, vomiting, diarrhea, followed up by fainting. I think we can tell your body is not doing well with you being out in the cold so much, getting beaten up, drinking, smoking, and not sleeping. 

According to a little bit of surface level research and skimming of articles about tuberculous meningitis within the National Library of Medicine, quite a few of Holden’s symptoms line up, even the ones related to his psyche (the disease actually can cause swelling of the brain, which can lead to delirium— something we’ve seen Holden suffer from a few times, even in the absence of alcohol). My last piece of evidence as to Holden’s potential hospitalization is that he says D.B. drives to visit him “nearly every weekend.” Essentially, I think that it’s very clear that Holden is at an institution where he’s been separated from all his vices, and treated for the potential hidden tuberculosis infection he’s been harboring that could have also damaged his mental health. The treatment he’s received has been able to help him manage himself to an extent where he finally actually is able to take the advice the adults around him give all the time– to “apply himself” and actually find a way to derive meaning from the world again.


Comments

  1. MitchellFebruary 26, 2026 at 10:33 AM

    This sounds like a plausible theory as to Holden's physical ailments at the end of his ordeal in New York, but of course he might well ALSO be suffering a psychological crisis, and it may well be related to his physical ills. I'm thinking of Holden in freezing Central Park after midnight, with wet hair, sitting on a bench wondering if he'll catch pneumonia and die. He gets ill largely because of the irresponsible way he's been living in New York over these lively two days, and that behavior has to do with his depression and his encroaching breakdown.

    Good catch on the subtle references to him "practically" getting "t.b." and "them" making him quit smoking, but there's also a reference to "this psychoanalyst guy" who he's been talking to. "Coming out here to take it easy" after "madman stuff" could refer equally to physical or psychological illness--and it's likely a potent combination of both.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is Esther Greenwood Homophobic?

Much like the rest of Plath’s comedic genius within The Belljar , Esther’s brief train of thought about homosexuality is incredibly hilarious. I cannot get the line “I wondered if all women did with other women was lie and hug” out of my head— no one will tell the poor girl anything about what lesbians actually do.  Esther’s first real introduction to gay behavior is when she forgets to leave after knocking on DeeDee’s door to no reply (218). She’s here to retrieve some sheet music, when she happens upon DeeDee and Joan vaguely lying on the bed together instead. We know it’s Joan because Esther describes “pale, pebble eyes regard[ing] me from the gloom,” and Esther had just finished ranting about how “horsey” Joan looked a page earlier: “I thought how sad it was Joan looked so horsey, with such big teeth and eyes like gray, goggly pebbles” (216). (Holden Horse Hypothesis, anyone? You know it’s Joan when the eyes are horsey goggly pebbles and you know it’s Doreen when they’re indest...
Read more

Rude Rejections vs Rose-tinted Reminiscence: Ramifications of the Reconstruction Period

Image
                 In class, we approached two different sets of readings approaching the Reconstruction era. In turn, the settings and attitudes of the characters featured in the readings initially approach the “opportunity” of Reconstruction differently.  In Chestnutt’s “The Wife of His Youth”, we see a very clear pattern in Mr. Ryder’s (and the Blue Veins Society’s) ideology; a sect of racism which modern readers currently name as colorism. This discrimination causes Mr. Ryder and other mixed Black people to internally reject their Black identity and heritage in favor of trying desperately to gain white validation. Of course, in “The Wife of His Youth” these characters are fictional, but the story intends on being a realistic portrayal or parallel to real life circumstances. In this sense, recovery from slavery is no more than a rejection of the past; of the previous collective Black identity as chattel .  The Blue Veins Socie...
Read more

Death =/= Determining Destiny

Image
          The first point in the Black Panther Party’s 10-point Program is the belief that  “Black people will not be free until we are able to determine our destiny,” described by the title “We Want Freedom. We Want Power To Determine The Destiny Of Our Black Community.”  The first poem we read representing the Black Arts movement was “For Black Poets Who Think of Suicide” by Etheridge Knight. Knight urges black poets not to commit suicide, as he designates suicide as a white activity--- an act of surrender which is made possible by having privilege. In contrast, “...Black Poets belong to Black People,” not death. In a philosophical sense, I do not believe there is any decision that gives one more agency, than the decision to decide to live. While killing oneself is a decision a person can make, no one can “determine their destiny” if they do not continue living. There is no way to have agency over one’s life if they are no longer living. ...
Read more